Fela!: Review Roundup

Sahr Ngaujah (center)

The return summer engagement of the 2009 bio-musical Fela!, based on the life of Fela Kuti as inspired by Carlos Moore’s book Fela: This Bitch of a Life, opened last night to somewhat mixed but generally positive reviews. For the record, the creative team includes Jim Lewis (book, addl. lyrics), Bill T. Jones (book, direction, choreography), Fela Kuti (lyrics, music), Aaron Johnson (addl. music, orchestration, music direction), Jordan McLean (addl. music), Marina Draghici (sets, costumes), Robert Wierzel (lights), Robert Kaplowitz (sound), Peter Nigrini (projections), and Cookie Jordan (hair, makeup). The cast includes Sahr Ngaujah (Fela), Paulette Ivory (Sandra), Rasaan-Elijah Green (Djembe-“Mustafa”), Ismael Kouyaté (Ismael), Gelan Lambert (Egungun, etc.), and Melanie Marshall (Funmilayo).

Dan Bacalzo (Theater Mania): Ultimately, the main reason to see Fela! remains the driving beat of the music coupled with the show’s highly kinetic dances. The talented company throw themselves into Jones’ spirited choreography, which is mostly characterized by hip gyrations that are both earthy and sexual.

Ben Brantley (N.Y. Times): Fela! incorporates the spirit of summertime insurrection as infectiously as any show I can think of. As staged by the choreographer Bill T. Jones, and written by Mr. Jones with Jim Lewis, Fela! translates one man’s life into a nonstop banquet of movement both sensuous and angry. And though this production has been on the road … it shows no signs whatsoever of flagging. … The number that best captures this production’s essence comes early. It’s a piece resonantly titled “Originality/Yellow Fever,” and it allows the different performers to embody the elements of Afrobeat style. There’s no question that they’re all drinking from the same musical source, but each also emerges as a brilliant solo artist. … In Fela! dancing isn’t just entertainment ­– it’s life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

Matthew Murray (Talkin’ Broadway): When the musical premiered Off-Broadway in 2008, and moved to the Main Stem the following year, it was in a suffocatingly environmental production that strove to not just immerse you but catapult you onstage. … This version of the show, simply put, can’t do that – and doesn’t really try. It’s understandable … but this innate inability has led to an evening that’s more conventional and less effective than what New York audiences had previously been exposed to. … You get a decent approximation but not the conflagration you’re constantly being promised. Still, these are concerns of sharpest interest to New Yorkers who’ve already experienced Fela! … If you somehow missed the show on its first two Manhattan appearances, this version is good enough to warrant a first look and a listen.

David Sheward (Back Stage): The touring version is making a brief Broadway summer stopover, but it feels more like a party than a challenging piece of political theater. … In the previous incarnations it felt as if the Nigerian army really was right outside of the stage door and you risked arrest just by being in your seat. It was thrillingly immediate and brought a dimension of fear to the proceedings. … Despite this ratcheting down of intensity, Sahr Ngaujah retains his blazing charisma and dazzling musical and dramatic versatility as he continues in his Tony-nominated performance of the title role. … Once again, a highlight of the show is an accelerating challenge dance in which each member of the powerhouse chorus gets a white-hot solo. But the real star is Ngaujah.

Posted in Broadway, Shows | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Ship Without a Sail: Book Reviews

Last week, Simon & Schuster released A Ship Without a Sail to overwhelmingly positive reviews. The new book from entertainment journalist Gary Marmorstein is being called the definitive biography of lyricist Lorenz Hart, the brilliant but troubled writing partner of composer Richard Rodgers, whose prolific collaboration lasted some 25 years, generating a groundwork of songs in the Great American Songbook as well as the landmark musical Pal Joey.

Dan Conway (Publishers Weekly): Journalist Marmorstein resists the temptation to psychoanalyze and instead explores Hart’s personality mainly through shrewd readings of his lyrics as they veer between “enthralling new romance and a lonely, unforgiving desolation.” He holds to a middle-distance perspective, organizing the narrative around lively accounts of Rodgers and Hart’s Broadway and Hollywood musical projects, with Hart’s self-destructive excesses surfacing in matter-of-fact vignettes amid the showbiz swirl. Along the way, he paints a vivid panorama of pre-WWII musical theater and the efflorescence of Jewish-American tune- and word-smithing that created it. Marmorstein’s take on his subject’s life feels like a Rodgers and Hart show, nicely balanced between exhilarating spectacle and pithy revelations of character.

John Fleming (Tampa Bay Times): Hart has his shining hour in a new biography by Gary Marmorstein. … It’s the absorbing story of a sparkling but tormented artist and a rich slice of show business history. … What most defines his portrait of this tragic figure is Hart’s alcoholism, which runs through the biography like a streak. It destroyed his relationship with Rodgers and finally killed him. A Ship Without a Sail quotes liberally from Hart’s lyrics, and Marmorstein’s analysis is always interesting and often revelatory. … Marmorstein’s exhaustive treatment of virtually every stage show and film with a score by Rodgers and Hart is both a valuable asset and an occasionally tedious shortfall. … Perhaps the best thing about this biography is that it makes you eager to hear the songs of Rodgers and Hart. In a “highly idiosyncratic” discography, Marmorstein supplies a selection of recordings that includes such delightful renditions as a lively duet of “The Lady Is a Tramp” by Tony Bennett and Lady Gaga.

J.D. McClathy (Wall St. Journal): Gary Marmorstein’s new book easily supplants Frederick Nolan’s ardent but choppy 1994 biography. If he is a bit prolix at times, he knows the period and its players inside out and along the way offers wonderful cameos of many minor figures in the story, from the director George Abbott to the dancer Vera Zorina. More important, he brings to the task just the right precision instruments for dissecting Larry Hart – panache, sympathy and smarts. The very title of his book goes to the heart of the tortured story he tells so well.

Bruce R. Schueneman (Library Journal): In this readable and thorough book, Marmorstein explores Hart’s ultimately destructive lifestyle as well as his complex relationship with Rodgers. The author examines a large slice of American popular culture of the period, especially theater, including material on George M. Cohan, Irving Berlin, Florenz Ziegfeld, Ed Wynn, and George Balanchine, among many others. … Though not a complete replacement of Frederick Nolan’s 1994 Lorenz Hart: A Poet on Broadway, which is based on extensive oral interviews, Marmorstein’s book has the advantage of copyright permission to reprint many Hart lyrics (which was denied to Nolan). This book is a worthy addition to the literature on the great American songbook. Recommended.

Posted in Books, Books & Media | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Summer Reading List

If you’re like me, you spent most of June catching up with this past season’s New York productions of musicals. Over a frenzied Memorial Day holiday in New York, I saw six shows in four days! As New York (and most regional) theaters pause before gearing up for next season, the summerstock months are the perfect time for catching up with this past year’s books about musicals – though at a more leisurely pace than a Tony Award rush weekend. Below is the selected list of publications from the 2011/12 season that I’d recommend for your summer reads. If you have any others to recommend, drop me a comment.

Album Produced By… [Bruce Kimmel]. In this honest memoir, Kimmel charts his career from Bay Cities to Varese Sarabande to the launch of his Kritzerland label. Of course, he writes about the stars on his recordings – including Elaine Stritch, Carol Channing, Donna Murphy, and Stephen Sondheim – and Kimmel has a gift for telling tales without grinding axes, though he is somewhat cutting about his colleagues at Varese and Fynsworth Alley. Most illuminating are his ideas on the songs he’s produced.

The Astaires: Fred & Adele [Kathleen Riley]. Before Fred and Ginger, there was Fred and Adele. In this first comprehensive study of the earlier duo, Riley traces the siblings from their humble Midwest origins to their vaudeville stardom and, ultimately, to their breakup when Adele married into aristocracy and Fred headed for Hollywood. In the process, Riley helps us understand the background that led to Fred’s later success.

Broadway Musical MVPs 1960-2010 [Peter Filichia]. Filichia is a perfect cheerleader for musicals and their creators. In this breezy collection of essays, he borrows the sports convention to explore fifty years of Broadway musical history – the MVP performers, producers, directors, and choreographers of each year in the past half-century. It is the perfect companion to his 2010 collection, Broadway Musicals: The Biggest Hit and the Biggest Flop of the Season.

The Irving Berlin Reader [Benjamin Sears]. Sears brings together a broad range of the most insightful primary and secondary writings about Berlin. Grouped by chronology, the some 40 pieces, many written by Berlin himself, include offerings from the earliest accounts of journalists to later recollections of his collaborators in their autobiographies. Reading these selections side by side lends a new perspective and appreciation of the composer’s genius.

Mr. Broadway: The Inside Story of the Shuberts, the Shows, and the Stars [Gerald Schoenfeld]. Completed one month before his death, Schonfeld’s autobiography is a captivating read. He recounts his rise from house lawyer to producer of Broadway’s greatest successes (A Chorus Line) and greatest misses (Amour). Yet this is not just the story of one man but of the last 70 years of Broadway. Schoenfeld often said he saved the Shuberts, and this memoir reveals how he did so, while also critically assessing many of his missteps along the way.

My Awesome/Awful Popularity Plan [Seth Rudetsky]. Justin may have the wrong look, the wrong hobbies, and the wrong friends, but he has the perfect plan to turn it all around. Rudetsky’s first novel for young adults is heartfelt and frequently laugh-out-loud funny. It’s not your average teen novel, but writer (and musical theater maven) Rudetsky is anything but average. Light-hearted and entertaining throughout, the book ends with a serious postscript to young readers having a hard time dealing with high school life.

Our Story: Jets and Sharks Then and Now [Original Film Cast]. In this collective memoir, a dozen surviving Jets and Sharks (and Girls) from West Side Story share their stories about the Oscar-winning film. Yet, it is not just about the movie, it’s about being a member of the tight-knit community of professional dancers. One of the most compelling stories is from Tony Mordente, who was cast as one of the film’s Jets, but whose wife Chita Rivera (the original Broadway Anita) wasn’t cast among the film’s Sharks.

A Purple Summer: Notes on the Lyrics of Spring Awakening [Steven Sater]. This brief paperback is precisely what the title implies: an insight into the lyrics of the Tony-winning musical. In vivid detail, Sater writes about the origins of the show’s songs and their development over the production’s eight-year gestation. He also writes about his partnership with composer Duncan Sheik and about working with the original cast members.

The Sound of Music Family Scrapbook [Fred Bronson]. For the first time, the children of the film tell their stories about making The Sound of Music, from auditions to rehearsals to their summer in Salzburg. As a bonus, there is a DVD with home movie footage, as well as numerous facsimiles stuffed into the book’s pockets – candid photos, letters home, diary pages, costume designs, premiere tickets, and more. It is a unique and interesting compilation.

Unnaturally Green: One Girl’s Journey Along a Yellow Brick Road Less Traveled [Felicia Ricci]. In January 2010, Ricci began her journey from selling software to understudying the green witch Elphaba in Wicked ­– her first professional gig … ever. This humorous memoir recounts the greenhorn’s journey, adapted from her blog entries like “Songs of Death” and “The Week I Didn’t Poop.” It may not be easy being green but is sure is fascinating.

Posted in Books, Books & Media | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Triassic Parq: Review Roundup

Wade McCollum (center)

The new Off-Broadway musical Triassic Parq, which won Best Musical at the 2010 N.Y. Fringe, opened to mixed but generally positive reviews. The creative team includes Marshall Pailet (book, lyrics, music, direction), Bryce Norbitz and Steve Wargo (book, lyrics), Kyle Mullins (choreography), Zak Sandler (musical direction), Dina Perez (costumes), Caite Hevner (sets), Jen Schriever (lights), and Michael Mulligan (puppets). The cast includes Lindsay Nicole Chambers, Brandon Espinoza, Wade McCollum, Claire Neumann, Lee Seymour, Shelley Thomas, and Alex Wyse.

Jennifer Farrar (AP): This hilarious, raunchy satire, with witty book and lyrics by Destiny (Marshall Pailet, Bryce Norbitz and Stephen Wargo), is loosely based on details from the 1990 book Jurassic Park. … Pailet’s direction is swift and sure, working with inventive choreography by Kyle Mullins and musical direction by Zak Sandler (Pianosaurus). The whole cast is terrific and energetic, colorfully costumed and prowling around the spooky, tropical-themed set. … The production team must be congratulated for creating the sounds and sights of a prehistoric jungle on a very small stage, with special kudos for the goat puppets. … This is one of the funniest psuedo-docudramas you’ll ever see, if you can hear it over the howls of laughter from the audience.

Eric Grode (N.Y. Times): Triassic Parq the Musical is overproduced and scattershot and a little bit desperate. It is also more than a little bit fun. This bawdy tribute to dinosaurs and their newfound genitalia doesn’t particularly make sense … but give the authors, Marshall Pailet, Bryce Norbitz and Stephen Wargo, a little time. Their material eventually settles into a contentedly sophomoric vibe, happy to show off here and pander there. There are worse things than seeing clever people try too hard. … The score by Mr. Pailet has at least two power ballads too many, although it also boasts the least embarrassing hip-hop number within a conventional book musical in recent memory.

Andy Propst (Theater Mania): Musicals don’t get much goofier than Triassic Parq The Musical … the fitfully amusing show about what might prompt genetically engineered dinosaurs (which are part of an island similar to the one in Jurassic Park) to run amok on a carnage-filled spree. … While the jokes about T-Rex 2’s over-estimation of her phallus incite initial giggles, they eventually become strained, as does Pailet’s uneven rock-pastiche music. Fortunately, along with the company’s fine performances, Kyle Mullins’ cracking choreography, Caite Hevner’s exceptional environmental scenic design, Dina Perez’s consistently witty costumes, and Jen Schriever’s eye-popping lighting design come together to often turn Triassic Parq into a guilty summertime pleasure.

David Sheward (Back Stage): If you want the theatrical equivalent of a quick bite, Triassic Parq is as nutritious and forgettable as a bag of chips. … This mini-musical has a sorta-funny premise, a whip-smart cast, frenetic staging, and an acidic sense of humor. But it will vanish from your mind the minute you hit the pavement outside the SoHo Playhouse. … It’s all harmless fun, staged at a dizzying pace by Pailet, who also composed the rock-flavored score. He and choreographer Kyle Mullins economically deploy the seven-member cast around Caite Hevner’s theme-park setting as if they were a troupe of well-trained acrobats. … Like the show’s dinosaurs, you’ll find yourself gobbling up this spicy snack in one gulp, but you’ll be hungry again soon afterward.

Elisabeth Vincentelli (N.Y. Post): Proudly cheap production values: check. Gratuitous profanity and risqué material covering toothless irreverence: check. Humor so broad, you could fly a jumbo jet through it: check. … Triassic Parq and its dino-inspired characters keep trying, but the nonsensical musical should be put permanently in park. … The show has no inner logic. While anthropomorphization is the name of the game in this kind of project, the dinos still have to behave somewhat in character – they know that even in Ice Age. Raptors are mean predators, not sweet oafs who sing, “It’s a beautiful day to be a woman / It’s a beautiful day / To hug the things I love.” It’s enough to make you reconsider the theory of evolution. 1½ stars.

Posted in Off-Broadway, Shows | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Love Never Dies: Video Reviews

Universal has released the video of Love Never Dies to mixed reviews. Filmed live in Melbourne, Australia, last September, the creative team includes Andrew Lloyd Webber (book and music), Glenn Slater (book and lyrics), Ben Elton (book), Charles Hart (additional lyrics), Simon Phillips (stage direction) and Brett Sullivan (film direction). The cast includes Ben Lewis (Phantom), Anna O’Byrne (Christine), Sharon Millerchip (Meg), Simon Gleeson (Raoul), Maria Mercedes (Madame), and Jack Lyll (Gustave).

Glen Pearce (Public Reviews): For those who saw the London original it’s almost unrecognizable: a new design, a new opening and ending and a much tighter emotional journey. Lloyd Webber’s score remains as lavish as ever but, at the heart, the tragic love story between the Phantom and Christine is now crystal clear. … The filming is beautiful, setting a new standard in theatrical recordings; high definition capturing every moment in lavish detail, multiple angles offering an intimacy for what is, when the spectacle is stripped away, a tragic love story. … The disappointing bonus feature aside this is a remarkable step forward in recording theatre for posterity. The Australian production may have restored Love Never Dies’ reputation, but the DVD also stands not only as a record of a landmark production but also of the potential for filming theatre productions for commercial release.

Eric Samdahl (Film Jabber): Did you ever wonder what happened to the Phantom of the Opera? Me neither, but that didn’t stop Andrew Lloyd Webber. … The play isn’t worth the trip. … Love Never Dies can’t escape the basic facts: it is a bigger and more extravagant production that lacks the intrigue and conflict of the original. In other words, it’s like so many other sequels. Bigger does not mean better. … On its own, Love Never Dies is an okay musical, but The Phantom of the Opera was never meant to end this way. Fans of Phantom will inevitably see the play, but it’s better to put it off for as long as possible.

Jorge Santos (Musical Chronicles): The idea of doing a sequel to a musical never really worked. … The story begins 10 years after the events of the original. Now, the Phantom lives in Coney Island, but it still misses Christine. When she arrives in New York, with Raoul and their son, following an invitation of Oscar Hammerstein, she soon discovers it was all a plan by the Phantom to reunite with her. Like the original, the design of this show looks amazing and director Simon Phillips takes full advantage of it. The problem is the plot; something doesn’t work. … We don’t care much for the characters and everything is very predictable. There aren’t any strong dramatic scenes and … nothing is very emotional. In fact, everything is kind of tedious and uninteresting. … If you like watching well-designed shows, with great sets, colorful costumes and listen to a few good songs, you can do worse than watching this Love Never Dies.

Kevin van der Ham (Movie Muser): Making a sequel is never easy, as fans of the original will always make comparisons. With this in mind, and giving Loving Never Dies a fair chance, we cannot ignore that this production has serious merit. … The execution of this is definitely sublime. Although it is very apparent that you are watching a recording of a live show, it has been filmed and edited in such a way as to take you right in, as if it was actually a movie filmed in a studio. … Regrettably, it’s the songs and the plot that let this film down. … Love Never Dies is a sterling effort and if it’s viewed on its own it is both enjoyable and a pleasure to watch. … This is a great film and is recommended viewing for musical theatre fans, but it’s missing the magic that the original music brought that we all fell in love with in the first place.

Posted in Books & Media, Videos | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Evita: Album Reviews

Last week, Sony Masterworks released the 2012 Broadway revival cast recording of Evita to generally positive reviews. The creative team includes Time Rice (book and lyrics), Andrew Lloyd Webber (music). The cast includes Ricky Martin (Ché), Michael Cerveris (Juan Perón), Elena Roger (Evita), Max von Essen (Magaldi) and Rachel Potter (Mistress).

Pip Ellwood (Entertainment Focus): Roger’s voice is of a higher pitch than previous Eva Perons and won’t be to everyone’s liking. … She is perhaps more suited to the gentler songs such as “You Must Love Me” and “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” than she is the more upbeat powerful songs. … Martin on the other hand shows a previously unheard power to his voice. … Michael Cerveris is also worthy of a mention. His duet with Roger on “I’d Be Surprisingly Good for You” is an early highlight with the two stars creating a believable chemistry with strong vocals. A bonus track on the release is the Spanish language version of “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina (No Llores por Mi Argentina).” Somehow the song sounds even more powerful in Spanish. … 3 stars.

Peter Filichia (Masterworks Broadway): The best revival cast albums don’t mirror what was placed on the original cast album; they add a little here and subtract a little there. This recording weighs in at six minutes longer, but that’s mostly because of two extra songs on disc two. Anyone who follows Broadway and Hollywood won’t need much time to guess what the first one is. When Evita was filmed, a new song was added, and as is the case with many Broadway revivals, the new song has been included here. … The other cut comes at the end as a bonus track. Roger reprises the show’s platinum hit, “Don’t Cry for Me, Argentina,” but this time in her native language. It’s quite impressive. There’s a good deal more dance music, too. The most spirited comes in “I’d Be Surprisingly Good for You.” … Even if you know previous recordings of Evita by heart, this one will be surprisingly good for you, too.

Andy Propst (Theater Mania): Perhaps chief among the reasons for adding the album to the shelf are the superb new orchestrations from Lloyd Webber and David Cullen, who have drastically revised their work from the 2006 British production (also starring Roger), which gave life to this revival. Their efforts not only enhance the music’s Latin flavor, but it also beautifully supports director Michael Grandage’s dramatically austere vision for the piece. Among the finest new sections is the sultry tango sequence that has been added to “I’d Be Surprisingly Good for You.” … Roger’s turn as Eva … will stir passionate debate, and yet there is little question that she brings fierceness and passion to the role. … The album – which includes a bonus track of Roger’s searing Spanish-language rendition of “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” – comes slipcased and with a full-color booklet that features pictures and lyrics along with a brief essay from Grandage about his vision for the show, which is so superlatively preserved on this genuinely rewarding set.

Joe Stead (Stage Style): The deluxe original Broadway cast album is a must-have for all musical theatre fans. … The currently running 2012 Broadway revival can really be summed up in two words: Ricky Martin. … Martin definitely has the vocal chops [but] I am not convinced … that Martin has any clue of this character’s biting cynicism. … Fortunately for Sony’s otherwise lavish recorded account, this interpretive difference does not completely mar what is still Webber and Rice’s finest (in my opinion) and most thrilling theatrical stage score. … The biggest liability of this new CD is Evita herself. Elena Roger is the first authentic Argentina-born actress to take on the title role in a major U.S. production, and it’s fun hearing the authenticity … but she’s a musical lightweight.

Posted in Albums, Books & Media, Revival Stage Cast | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Closer Than Ever: Review Roundup

Dvorsky, Noll, Viviano, Colella

Last week, York Theatre Company opened its Off-Broadway revival of the 1989 revue Closer Than Ever to very positive reviews. The creative team includes Richard Maltby Jr. (concept, lyrics, direction), David Shire (music), Scott Smith (concept), Andrew Gerle (music direction), Kurt Stamm (choreography), James Morgan (sets), Nicole Wee (costumes), and Kirk Bookman (lights). The cast includes Jenn Colella, George Dvorsky, Christiane Noll, Sal Viviano.

Eric Grode (N.Y. Times): Musical theater has courted young audiences relentlessly in the 23 years since Closer Than Ever opened Off-Broadway. But among the abundant charms of this pocket-sized 1989 revue, now getting a polished revival by the York Theater Company, is its assertion that folks with a few miles on the odometer also have stuff to sing about. More stuff, in fact. … The score by David Shire and lyrics by Richard Maltby Jr., who also directed the piece, look long and hard at what one song calls “The March of Time,” and the four performers are both rueful and relieved about what they find. Mr. Shire’s score continually finds the jaunty rhythms in even the most melancholy subjects. … Charming material presented charmingly and sometimes marvelously: unlike the men and women on either side of the footlights, that combination will never get old.

Brian Scott Lipton (Theater Mania): Richard Maltby Jr. and David Shire’s deliciously tuneful, often pungent musical revue Closer Than Ever, now at the York Theatre Company, feels just as fresh as it did when many of us first heard it 23 years ago. But there are number of equally compelling reasons ­­­– aside from the pair’s instantly memorable melodies and smartly crafted lyrics – for the enterprise’s current success. To begin, there’s Maltby’s simple but sprightly direction in which he guides his exemplary cast. … Maltby has wisely done minimal updating to his lyrics, and the clearest indication of the show’s 2012 setting is a proliferation of iPhones as props. But having a group of performers who are considerably older than their original Off-Broadway counterparts (Lynne Winterstellar, Sally Mayes, Richard Muenz, and Brent Barrett) adds a level of poignancy to the numbers.

David A. Rosenberg (Back Stage): The revue, with energetic direction by lyricist Maltby and breezy, romantic music by David Shire, is both good-natured and harmless, displaying touches of genuine feeling as it runs lightly over an era of missed opportunities. To its credit, the revival is enacted with devotion by a quartet of polished singers who turn the varied show melodies into art songs. … New additions to the evening are “I’ll Get Up Tomorrow Morning” and “There Is Something in a Wedding,” which deals with fights, divorces, and all that passes for love these days. Dropped from the original is “Music Everywhere,” about the chokehold Muzak once had on a generation. Added are references to DVR, iPhones, and Glenn Beck. But essentials never change; as the soaring “Patterns” declares, “Why are patterns haunting every move I make?” Yet salvation comes. As “If I Sing” has it: “There is joy in making music.”

Frank Scheck (N.Y. Post): Closer Than Ever, now receiving a sterling revival by the York Theatre Company, contains plenty of story lines – two dozen, to be exact. Each of the 24 numbers in David Shire and Richard Maltby Jr.’s show … seems more like a concise one-act play. Dealing as it does with themes of loss, love and dreams both fulfilled and unrequited, it’s like a musical manual for the middle-aged. The tone ranges from comic to bittersweet to downright tragic, but warmth and wisdom resonate throughout. If you can’t find something to relate to here, you simply haven’t lived or loved. A spot-on foursome of actors … skillfully navigates the tonal shifts of this alternately funny, poignant and insightful show.

Posted in Off-Broadway, Shows | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Queen of the Mist: Album Reviews

This week, Ghostlight Records released the original cast recording of this past season’s Off-Broadway musical Queen of the Mist to generally positive reviews. The creative team includes Michael John LaChiusa (book, lyrics, music), Chris Fenwick (music direction), Michael Starobin (orchestration), and Walter Trarbach (sound effects). The cast includes Mary Testa with D.C. Anderson, Stanley Bahorek, Theresa McCarthy, Julia Murney, Andrew Samonsky, and Tally Sessions.

Steve Bergman (Edge): Testa is a frequent interpreter of LaChiusa’s work, and admirably proves her ability to effectively navigate his score, and yet she still provides the humanity necessary to pull off this potentially unlikable woman. LaChiusa has proven himself an accomplished and knowledgeable creator of works in both the musical theater and opera worlds. His music is accessible, yet complex, drawing the listener into the world of the story and challenging them to take away more than merely hummable show tunes, without offending them into leaving the experience too early. Mixing various musical styles, all centered on the turn of the 20th century, LaChiusa has written another timeless score that should attract a subset of regional theaters that seek out these works.

David Hurst (Next): Only the brilliant and eclectic Michael John LaChiusa could compose a musical about Anna Edson Taylor, the first person to survive going over Niagara Falls in a barrel (in 1901 at the age of 63!). Boasting a superb cast led by the galvanizing performances of Mary Testa as Taylor and Andrew Samonsky as her unscrupulous promoter, LaChiusa’s score is as tuneful as it is terrific.

Joe Stead (Chicago Stage Style): I doubt I will be joining the Michael John LaChiusa fan club any time soon. … Queen of the Mist may be fated for legend, but more of a legendary flop if anything. Mary Testa’s ear-shattering portrayal of this pathetic phenomenon of “horrific beauty” has all the charm of a cat in heat. It actually took me three attempts to make it through this shrill and unpleasant cast album. … The author obviously sees Annie Edson Taylor as some kind of deranged but fascinating heroine, damaged but worthy goods. Maybe it worked better in a theatre where visual invention and ingenuity could compensate for the screechy vaudeville pastiche score. … It left me with a headache.

Posted in Albums, Books & Media, Original Stage Cast | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

In Memoriam: Richard Adler

Composer Richard Adler, co-creator of the classic musicals The Pajama Game and Damn Yankees, died last night at his home in Southampton, N.Y. He was 90 and among the last of Broadway’s Golden Age writers. When I created The Dramatist magazine for the Dramatists Guild, I set out to interview as many of my theatrical heroes as I could. Adler was one of the first.

I arrived at his East Side duplex for what was supposed to be a 30-minute session. His apartment was not decorated with theater memorabilia, as I had expected, but with personal mementos (photos on the grand piano of him and Marilyn Monroe at the famed birthday party he produced for President Kennedy, an autographed picture of him and Jackie O at the dedication of the Kennedy Center) and a stunning collection of art, including a wall of Picasso pottery and a Gauguin fan that the Metropolitan Museum borrowed for a 2002 exhibit on the artist.

I left two hours later, only after I had run out of audiotape. Despite the half century between us, it was like the easy conversation between longtime friends. After the article appeared in print, I was pleasantly surprised to receive an inscribed copy of his autobiography, You Gotta Have Heart, and an invitation for another meal, this time just to chat. Every other month thereafter, we met for lunch and talked shop.

I will always be grateful for his friendship and for his advice as I began my journey as a lyricist in the BMI workshop.

Posted in People, Writers | Tagged | Leave a comment

Rock of Ages: Review Roundup

Tom Cruise

Rock of Ages, the $75 million film adaptation of the 2009 Tony-nominated Broadway musical, took in an underwhelming $15.1 million in its first weekend, though it has received generally positive reviews. The creative team includes Adam Shankman (direction), Justin Theroux, Chris D’Arienzo and Allan Loeb (screenplay), Bojan Bazelli (cinematography), Emma E. Hickox (editing), Adam Anders and Peer Astrom (score), Mia Michaels (choreography), Jon Hutman (production design), and Rita Ryack (costumes).

The cast includes Julianne Hough (Sherrie), Diego Boneta (Drew), Paul Giamatti (Paul Gill), Russell Brand (Lonny), Mary J. Blige (Justice), Angelo Donato Valderrama (Chico), Malin Akerman (Constance), Bryan Cranston (Mike Whitmore), Catherine Zeta-Jones (Patricia Whitmore), Alec Baldwin (Dennis Dupree), and Tom Cruise (Stacee Jaxx). Rated PG-13.

Manohla Dargis (N.Y. Times): Rock of Ages … is just entertaining enough to keep you from dark thoughts about the state of Hollywood. The movie is too insipid for such hand wringing. … The whole thing rests on a, er, bedrock of clichés from Hollywood’s favorite genre: movies about itself. This Wonder Bread banality comes from how thoroughly Mr. Shankman has vacuumed his rock-scene simulacrum of anything recognizably rock, including the lust, juice, heat, bad behavior and excesses that characterize its real-life analogue. There isn’t any grit to these people or their art, not a speck of dirt anywhere. It looks like Disneyland and sounds, well, like a bad Broadway musical, with all the power belting and jazz-hand choreography that implies. … All the songs are sung, mostly without shame or distinction, by the actors themselves, who slide into the warbling as if into a conversation.

Roger Ebert (Chicago Sun Times): A lot of it is zesty entertainment, with some energetic musical numbers; several big names (Tom Cruise, Russell Brand, Alec Baldwin) prove they can sing well enough. … Adam Shankman’s Rock of Ages not only has a high-profile cast, but they never seem to be slumming; they play their roles with great intensity and earnestness, which is really the only way to do satire. … There isn’t an original idea in the screenplay by Justin Theroux and Chris D’Arienzo, based on an Off-Broadway hit. Even the songs are oldies. And that’s OK, because the actors are having a lot of fun, and the production values of the musical numbers are slick and high-spirited. The only problem is that the plot meanders when nobody is singing.

Christy Lemire (AP): Your enjoyment of this musical, based on the Tony-nominated Broadway show, will depend greatly on your enjoyment of this music. … Sure, the characters are all broad types, from fresh-faced newcomers with dreams of stardom to grizzled, cynical veterans who’ve seen it all. And sure, their antics are glossed-up and watered-down compared to reality to ensure a PG-13 accessibility. But the movie has enough energy to keep you suitably entertained, as well as a knowing, cheeky streak that prevents it from turning too reverent and self-serious. … Two and a half stars out of four.

Kenneth Turan (L.A. Times): A triumph of genial impudence over good sense and better taste, Rock of Ages is the guiltiest of guilty pleasures. Blessed with unstoppable energy, an undeniably bawdy sense of fun and Tom Cruise in backless leather pants, it takes songs you may never have loved and turns them into a musical that’s easy to enjoy. … Its essential sweetness leavened by knowing winks, Rock of Ages succeeds as well as it does because of its unlikely combination of a guileless, thunderously clichéd boy-meets-girl plot structure conveyed in a sophisticated, showbiz-savvy style. The film is also filled with actors willing to dive headfirst into their roles and take the endeavor’s inherent foolishness seriously, all with an eye toward enhancing the audience’s fun.

Posted in Film, Shows | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment